www.ukengineforum.forumotion.com
Please log in , the forum is open to guests who are now able to view most sections, feel free to become a member , you will then be able to post and reply to topics.

Join the forum, it's quick and easy

www.ukengineforum.forumotion.com
Please log in , the forum is open to guests who are now able to view most sections, feel free to become a member , you will then be able to post and reply to topics.

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

4 posters

Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by chrismac Sat Jul 10 2021, 18:01


I have a fire pump fitted with a ford 1600 petrol engine, unfortunately it has stopped charging the battery, having stripped it back to access the regulator it would seem going by the fault finding steps in the Godiva manual the regulator has given up the ghost.

Is it possible to repair these units, are there any alternatives which I could fit or must it be like for like.

The Boyers Brandsen company still is in operation but I thought I would ask here to see if anyone has had any experience with these units and if a know replacement is available.

There is a plug which has 2 yellow wires and a red from the alternator, the red red/white and white all connect into one connector heading to the ignition on/off, (push button to start) with the brown going to the charging lamp, and black to ground, I started the pump with a lamp between the 2 yellow wires from the alternator and it lit so alternator is fine.

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  51303186879_6c6ffca8da_zUntitled by chrismac2012, on Flickr

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  51302661293_0be9024843_zUntitled by chrismac2012, on Flickr

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  51302467646_405521844e_zUntitled by chrismac2012, on Flickr

Thanks for taking the time to have a look.

Chris



chrismac
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 164
Join date : 2013-07-12
Age : 48
Location : Wick, Caithness

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by mattblack Sat Jul 10 2021, 21:22

What Ford engine is it? (looks like a possibly a CVH?), I'm thinking you could fit an alternator with built in regulator from whatever car it was fitted to.

_________________
Specialist in precision guesswork.
mattblack
mattblack
Life Member
Life Member

Posts : 889
Join date : 2019-06-21
Location : Leicester, me duck...

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by chrismac Sat Jul 10 2021, 21:54

There is no auxiliary belt the fan is bolted on the the crank, yes it is the cvh engine, it could be done I guess with some work, cutting the guards but hoping to have a as near like for like fix if possible,
Cheers

chrismac
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 164
Join date : 2013-07-12
Age : 48
Location : Wick, Caithness

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by Robotstar5 Sat Jul 10 2021, 23:02

Do you have a link to the wiring diagram?, it may give me a few ideas.

_________________
Stuart
Robotstar5
Robotstar5
Life Member
Life Member

Posts : 1110
Join date : 2018-09-25

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by mattblack Sun Jul 11 2021, 08:27

chrismac wrote:There is no auxiliary belt the fan is bolted on the the crank, yes it is the cvh engine, it could be done I guess with some work, cutting the guards but hoping to have a as near like for like fix if possible,
Cheers

How is the alternator driven now?

An auto electrician with experience of older cars may be able to help, the only alternator with a separate regulator I can remember was on a 60's Humber Sceptre I had many years ago.

_________________
Specialist in precision guesswork.
mattblack
mattblack
Life Member
Life Member

Posts : 889
Join date : 2019-06-21
Location : Leicester, me duck...

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by chrismac Sun Jul 11 2021, 17:34

Robotstar5 wrote:Do you have a link to the wiring diagram?, it may give me a few ideas.

Will do, I'll get it in a wee while, thanks in advance,

Chris

chrismac
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 164
Join date : 2013-07-12
Age : 48
Location : Wick, Caithness

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by chrismac Sun Jul 11 2021, 17:38

mattblack wrote:
chrismac wrote:There is no auxiliary belt the fan is bolted on the the crank, yes it is the cvh engine, it could be done I guess with some work, cutting the guards but hoping to have a as near like for like fix if possible,
Cheers

How is the alternator driven now?

An auto electrician with experience of older cars may be able to help, the only alternator with a separate regulator I can remember was on a 60's Humber Sceptre I had many years ago.

Its direct drive, it slips over the pump shaft, quite a unique set up for a car engine,

chrismac
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 164
Join date : 2013-07-12
Age : 48
Location : Wick, Caithness

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by chrismac Sun Jul 11 2021, 19:14

Alternator location 3rd from the right in the middle image

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  51305797585_5461d71d5a_zPump Alternator by chrismac2012, on Flickr

Wiring diagram, hopefully there is some relevant info there,

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  51304041982_e1d9b36ddb_zPump Wiring diagram by chrismac2012, on Flickr

Chris

chrismac
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 164
Join date : 2013-07-12
Age : 48
Location : Wick, Caithness

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by Robotstar5 Sun Jul 11 2021, 21:35

I'm at a loss, I can't match the diagram with your photo of the alternator control unit, the diagram doesn't seem to show it

_________________
Stuart
Robotstar5
Robotstar5
Life Member
Life Member

Posts : 1110
Join date : 2018-09-25

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by chrismac Mon Jul 12 2021, 07:57

Robotstar5 wrote:I'm at a loss, I can't match the diagram with your photo of the alternator control unit, the diagram doesn't seem to show it

Yep that seems to be the way of it, I am wondering if when the Godiva wrote the manual there was no component fault finding to be carried out, meaning the wiring diagram only shows the actual wires rather than a full diagram, Thanks for trying to take a look.

Chris

chrismac
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 164
Join date : 2013-07-12
Age : 48
Location : Wick, Caithness

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by oldgit Mon Jul 12 2021, 12:24

I can't see from the pictures what type of alternator is fitted.
Having looked at the Boyer Bransden site; it looks like their regulators are for permanent magnet alternators, I don't know how they regulate. I suppose they disconnect the output to the battery when the cycle voltage reaches 15volts.

The vehicle alternator type uses an electromagnet. as opposed to a permanent magnet, and the external regulator would switch the supply to this off when the circuit voltage reached 14-15volts. So this would be of no use to you.

Someone may well know better.

George.

oldgit
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 168
Join date : 2019-07-07

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by chrismac Mon Jul 12 2021, 19:30

Robotstar5 wrote:I'm at a loss, I can't match the diagram with your photo of the alternator control unit, the diagram doesn't seem to show it

I have very roughly attempted to draw the voltage regulator on the drawing previously added with the wires of interest going to where they go.

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  51307821854_d220c4b518_zUntitled by chrismac2012, on Flickr

I have sent an email to Boyer Bransden to see if they can help, I am not holding out much hope as Godiva seem to have their stuff quite inaccessible for the general public to purchase,  thats why I was hoping one the the general units supplied from them or someone else might be an alternative, I think I have not gathered the alternator is 3 phase. thats relevant in the replacement but does not mean a lot to me, I caertainly know its not 440v its spitting out, or at least I hope not.. Very Happy

Another question, is it possible to open up the box and replace the damaged component, I know its filled with some epoxy type electrical stuff to seal it all up, I just wondered if thats an option. nothing ventured and nothing gained sort of thing.

Chris

chrismac
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 164
Join date : 2013-07-12
Age : 48
Location : Wick, Caithness

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by chrismac Mon Jul 12 2021, 19:33

oldgit wrote: I can't see from the pictures what type of alternator is fitted.
Having looked at the Boyer Bransden site; it looks like their regulators are for permanent magnet alternators, I don't know how they regulate. I suppose they disconnect the output to the battery when the cycle voltage reaches 15volts.

The vehicle alternator type uses an electromagnet. as opposed to a permanent magnet, and the external regulator would switch the supply to this off when the circuit voltage reached 14-15volts. So this would be of no use to you.
 
Someone may well know better.

George.

I also dont know and that information is not easy to get, I might phone or email Godiva to see if they have anyone who can assist,

Thanks
Chris

chrismac
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 164
Join date : 2013-07-12
Age : 48
Location : Wick, Caithness

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by mattblack Mon Jul 12 2021, 21:22

I could ask on a hot rod forum I go on if you like, lots of knowledgeable people on there.

I still think an auto (or maybe plant) electrician could have the answer, the location of the alternator is unconventional but surely the principal will be the same, it will be putting out AC which is rectified/regulated by the external unit to around 14.4V DC to charge the battery?

_________________
Specialist in precision guesswork.
mattblack
mattblack
Life Member
Life Member

Posts : 889
Join date : 2019-06-21
Location : Leicester, me duck...

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by chrismac Mon Jul 12 2021, 22:21

mattblack wrote:I could ask on a hot rod forum I go on if you like, lots of knowledgeable people on there.

I still think an auto (or maybe plant) electrician could have the answer, the location of the alternator is unconventional but surely the principal will be the same, it will be putting out AC which is rectified/regulated by the external unit to around 14.4V DC to charge the battery?

If its not too much hassle feel free, I agree with out knowing too much about it yet, I'll be better placed if it gets fixed, you would think something that does the regulating for any type of thing like this would be more or less the same, I still cant work out how it charges the battery, must just be a trickle feed as there are no heavy wires that I can see apart from the battery terminal connections.

Cheers Chris

chrismac
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 164
Join date : 2013-07-12
Age : 48
Location : Wick, Caithness

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by oldgit Mon Jul 12 2021, 23:21

I have a job to read anything on that wiring diagram, I've tried wearing 5 pairs of specs at once, and a loupe; but it looks to me that the output from the alternator, after passing through the regulator comes through a fuse on a sub panel and joins the permanently live wire between the starter and the start switch.

This system is handy for this application; it's done away with a drive belt and brushes which is two less things to go wrong.

A motorcycle electrician might know; as I think they may use permanent magnet alternators.

oldgit
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 168
Join date : 2019-07-07

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by oldgit Mon Jul 12 2021, 23:29

Regarding the regulators, the usual vehicle type controls the strength of the magnetism in the rotor to regulate the output.
The strength of the magnetism in the permanent magnet type is fixed; so it needs a different method to limit the output.

good luck with this.

oldgit
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 168
Join date : 2019-07-07

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by mattblack Wed Jul 14 2021, 17:41

I posted this thread up on the forum, someone has suggested that Harleys (and other bikes) use similar permanent magnet alternators so a motorbike shop/electrician may have the answer?

_________________
Specialist in precision guesswork.
mattblack
mattblack
Life Member
Life Member

Posts : 889
Join date : 2019-06-21
Location : Leicester, me duck...

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by Robotstar5 Wed Jul 14 2021, 17:54

OK, after a bit of searching I found this

https://www.feked.com/boyer-three-phase-12v-power-box-alternator-regulator-with-charging-light-control.html

All the wires from your present unit confused me until I realised Red, Red/White and White are linked so they would be replaced by the Red wire on the above unit Thumbs Up

One of the pictures shows all the connections so I won't repeat them, but happy to clarify anything.

_________________
Stuart
Robotstar5
Robotstar5
Life Member
Life Member

Posts : 1110
Join date : 2018-09-25

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by chrismac Thu Jul 22 2021, 22:05

Robotstar5 wrote:OK, after a bit of searching I found this

https://www.feked.com/boyer-three-phase-12v-power-box-alternator-regulator-with-charging-light-control.html

All the wires from your present unit confused me until I realised Red, Red/White and White are linked so they would be replaced by the Red wire on the above unit Thumbs Up

One of the pictures shows all the connections so I won't repeat them, but happy to clarify anything.

Thanks for your help, to update, the replacement was fitted and we are now charging Very Happy as all is well.

Chris

chrismac
A true Stationary engine owner
A true Stationary engine owner

Posts : 164
Join date : 2013-07-12
Age : 48
Location : Wick, Caithness

Back to top Go down

Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.  Empty Re: Something for the electrical gurus, help please of sussing out a replacement voltage regulator.

Post by Sponsored content


Sponsored content


Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum